Evidence-Based Practice Proposal
PART 1An EBP proposal is like a road map or a thoroughly thought out plan to improve patient safety and quality of care. Evidence-Based Practice in nursing focuses on the idea that medical practices ought to be developed and adapted based on an ongoing cycle of evidence.Instructions:Develop a one-page topic proposal that should include:
- Briefly describe and explain your evidence-based topic and its importance.
- You should describe why you think this topic is particularly relevant to our practice and why it is an important area of study.
- Do we have a need for change and why?
- Be specific what unit or patient population within an organization.
- What is the Purpose of your project? What are trying to achieve?
- What “sparked” you to look up evidence about this problem (why do you care)?
- What are the anticipated outcomes (benefits) if the problem goes away?
- View grading rubric grading rubric
NUR3165 – Nursing Research
Evidence-Based Practice – Part 1
Proposal
Criteria Outstanding Acceptable Unacceptable
Statement of PICO
Questions
(Population;
Intervention;
Comparison Group;
Outcome)
1 points
Correct format
followed: Each element
addressed with detail
and correctly
.5 point
Correct format followed
but information not
correctly identified
0 point
Correct format not
followed: PICO
elements not clearly
identified
Introduction 1 points
The introduction is
engaging,
states the main topic and
is clearly stated and
discussed.
.5 point
Introduction stated with
some discussion.
0 point
The introduction is
disorganized with not
clear main topic
Clear statement of the
research problem
Scope of the problem
1 points
Problem clearly stated
and discussed.
.5 point
Problem stated with
minimal discussion.
0 point
Problem statement not
included.
Purpose of the paper 1 points
Establishes strong sense
of purpose, either
explicitly or implicitly.
.5 point
Purpose or controlling idea
is established initially, but
inconsistently attended to.
Paper shows some unity of
purpose, though some
material may not be well
aligned.
0 point
Fails to establish purpose
for writing.
No clear point or
purpose; no central
argument to paper.
Paper drifts substantially
from initial purpose or
controlling idea
APA Citation and
References
1 points
APA format corrects.
References correct.
.5 point
APA format with some
errors. References with
some errors
0 point
APA format is not used.
References not cited
TOTAL 5 points
9/24/21, 3)25 PMAsking the Searchable and Answerable Question
Page 1 of 2https://mdc.blackboard.com/bbcswebdav/pid-10889774-dt-content-rid…NUR3165-2217-4623/2213_FIX_Lectures/Lesson_4/Lesson41120203.html
Asking the Searchable and
Answerable Question
Determine the type of question (therapy, dx, prognosis)
Finding the right information in the most efficient manner is key
to successfully practicing evidence-based decision making.
Developing the question requires:
You may have a question about:
Intervention (that is, treatment)—for example, in
adults with rheumatoid arthritis, is education about
joint protection techniques effective in reducing
hand pain and improving function?
Diagnosis for example, in adults admitted to a
Coronary care Unit, which elements of serial
diagnostic testing are the most sensitive and specific predictors of
cardiac involvement?
Prognosis for example, in people undergoing total knee replacement
for osteoarthritis, what improvement in walking ability is expected
after six weeks?
Evidence Based Practice
Asking the Relevant Clinical Question
9/24/21, 3)25 PMAsking the Searchable and Answerable Question
Page 2 of 2https://mdc.blackboard.com/bbcswebdav/pid-10889774-dt-content-rid…NUR3165-2217-4623/2213_FIX_Lectures/Lesson_4/Lesson41120203.html
Clients’ experiences and concerns, understanding of the patient
and what are the outcomes and beliefs that matter to this patient
Death? Disability? Quality of life? Cost? Improvement of
symptoms?
9/24/21, 3)25 PMThe Need for Change
Page 1 of 3https://mdc.blackboard.com/bbcswebdav/pid-10889774-dt-content-rid…NUR3165-2217-4623/2213_FIX_Lectures/Lesson_4/Lesson41120202.html
The Need for Change
Many questions arise during patient care. Some are general
questions about a clinical problem or a disease process.
Before Choosing your EBP questions you must identify the
following:
Asses your Practice
The assessment of
practice drives the
formulation of a clinical
question that can be
answered from research,
clinical judgment, and
patient preferences.
Identify
Need for
Change
It is important to identify where the need for change
has arisen.
It may be related to new knowledge that needs to be
Evidence Based Practice
Asking the Relevant Clinical Question
9/24/21, 3)25 PMThe Need for Change
Page 2 of 3https://mdc.blackboard.com/bbcswebdav/pid-10889774-dt-content-rid…NUR3165-2217-4623/2213_FIX_Lectures/Lesson_4/Lesson41120202.html
examined for implementation into the clinical setting.
It may be related to a clinical problem which has been
identified by clinicians and existing knowledge is being sought
to provide solutions or improvements to the clinical problem.
Identify Change Agents
The earlier that participants who will be instrumental in
bringing about the change are identified and included in the
process, the more likely the change is to be successful.
Identify Target Audience
In this step, those who will be affected by
the change are identified so the practice
change can be tailored to fit the audience.
Identify
Stakeholders
Knowing the individuals or groups who have a vested interest
in the project and anticipating their acceptance, support, or
resistance is critical to the success of the project.
9/24/21, 3)25 PMThe Need for Change
Page 3 of 3https://mdc.blackboard.com/bbcswebdav/pid-10889774-dt-content-rid…NUR3165-2217-4623/2213_FIX_Lectures/Lesson_4/Lesson41120202.html
Identify Problem and
Formulate a Specific
Question
There are many reasons nurses may start to look for evidence
to inform a decision they would wish to make: it could be to
support a change of practice, to consider the best option from
a range of choices or to do a cost comparison of different
forms of treatment.
Whatever the reason the first place to start is by Formulate
an answerable question.
Why formulate a clear clinical question?
If done properly it can help you to:
Locate the evidence quickly
Determine what you already know or don’t know about the
issue
Decide what you really need to know vs. “the nice to know”
Helps to clarify your ideas
Help you to search for the evidence effectively
Help you save time
9/24/21, 3)25 PMDefining a Nursing Problem
Page 1 of 2https://mdc.blackboard.com/bbcswebdav/pid-10889774-dt-content-rid…NUR3165-2217-4623/2213_FIX_Lectures/Lesson_4/Lesson41120205.html
Defining a Nursing Problem
The PICOT Principle
PICOT is a taxonomy
used in evidence-based
practice to help
formulate questions.
PICOT is a framework
that clinicians can use to formulate effective clinical
questions in a step-by-step manner.
PICOT is not prescriptive in that it doesn’t tell you how to do
an intervention or a comparison. You have to make those
determinations.
A focused question allows you to create a search strategy
that will get you relevant, precise results.
For example treatment of Pneumococcal Pneumonia SHOULD be
different for
Terminal Cancer Patient
Elderly, Severely Demented Patient
Young, mother of 2 children
Evidence Based Practice
Asking the Relevant Clinical Question
9/24/21, 3)25 PMDefining a Nursing Problem
Page 2 of 2https://mdc.blackboard.com/bbcswebdav/pid-10889774-dt-content-rid…NUR3165-2217-4623/2213_FIX_Lectures/Lesson_4/Lesson41120205.html
What to include what to
exclude?
Identifying the relevance to situational practice and how it
improves the present patient experience.
9/24/21, 3)25 PMFraming the Clinical Question for Making Search Decisions
Page 1 of 3https://mdc.blackboard.com/bbcswebdav/pid-10889774-dt-content-rid…NUR3165-2217-4623/2213_FIX_Lectures/Lesson_4/Lesson41120204.html
Framing the Clinical Question
for Making Search Decisions
Background Questions:
Background questions are formulated to
look for general knowledge or ‘facts’ or
etiology: Who, what, when, why, how
What are the differential diagnostic
criteria for meningitis?
What are the side effects of Morphine?
What are the risk factors for extravasation in neonates
receiving peripheral IV fluids?
How is HCV transmitted?
Best answers are often found in textbooks or databases like
UpToDate , DynaMed.
“Patient Centered Questions”
Evidence Based Practice
Asking the Relevant Clinical Question
9/24/21, 3)25 PMFraming the Clinical Question for Making Search Decisions
Page 2 of 3https://mdc.blackboard.com/bbcswebdav/pid-10889774-dt-content-rid…NUR3165-2217-4623/2213_FIX_Lectures/Lesson_4/Lesson41120204.html
Foreground Questions
Foreground questions ask for specific
knowledge one can apply to a specific
patient or problem.
They often compare two things: two
drugs or treatments, the prognosis of
two groups, two diagnostic tests, or the
harms or benefits of two approaches.
They often require primary sources that synthesize a wide range
of knowledge, and are more difficult to answer than background
questions.To formulate a good foreground question, practitioners
apply the acronym P-I-C-O-T also known as “PICOT” as a
framework to outline the clinical question.
Hand washing helps to prevent the spread of nosocomial
infections. Is the use of soap and water or alcohol-based rubs
more effective in preventing these infections?
Hip fracture is common in elderly patients after falling. I have
an elderly patient who exhibits an unsteady gait. Would a hip
protector be a useful preventative measure for this patient?
The physician prescribes warfarin to control an elderly
patient’s atrial fibrillation. What is the major risk associated
with the drug? Should dosage level be a concern in the elderly
population?
In middle aged women with migraine headaches, is there any
evidence that acupuncture compared to sham treatment,
biofeedback, relaxation training, and cognitive-behavioral
9/24/21, 3)25 PMFraming the Clinical Question for Making Search Decisions
Page 3 of 3https://mdc.blackboard.com/bbcswebdav/pid-10889774-dt-content-rid…NUR3165-2217-4623/2213_FIX_Lectures/Lesson_4/Lesson41120204.html
therapy
9/24/21, 3)26 PM What Makes a Clinical Question Well Built?
Page 1 of 2https://mdc.blackboard.com/bbcswebdav/pid-10889774-dt-content-rid…NUR3165-2217-4623/2213_FIX_Lectures/Lesson_4/Lesson41120209.html
What Makes a Clinical
Question Well Built?
In the scenario about Mrs. R one
foreground question may be,
“In this middle-aged Hispanic woman
whose is slightly obese with moderate
hypertension (the P), would treating her
(the I) with a weight loss plan (the C) be
beneficial to reduce her blood pressure
(the O)?”
Remember!
Question should be directly relevant to the problem at hand.
Question should be phrased to facilitate searching for a precise
answer.
Asking a well-built question, like many clinical skills, needs practice.
If you would like more practice go to the Center for EBM Toronto
and Practice Formulating Questions (https://ebm-
tools.knowledgetranslation.net/resource/formulating-answerable)
Evidence Based Practice
Asking the Relevant Clinical Question
9/24/21, 3)26 PM What Makes a Clinical Question Well Built?
Page 2 of 2https://mdc.blackboard.com/bbcswebdav/pid-10889774-dt-content-rid…NUR3165-2217-4623/2213_FIX_Lectures/Lesson_4/Lesson41120209.html
Resources for PICOT
Several sources are available to help nurses develop PICOT
questions. Below are some links to valuable resources.
Florida Gulf Coast University Library PICO tutorial :
https://fgcu.libguides.com/EBP/pic
(https://fgcu.libguides.com/EBP/pico)
University of North Carolina–Chapel Hill Health Science Library:
http://www.hsl.unc.edu/services/tutorials/pico_tutorial/index.cfm
(https://guides.lib.unc.edu/pico)
Boston University: http://medlib.bu.edu/tutorials/ebm/pico
(http://www.bumc.bu.edu/medlib/resources/tutorials/ebmebd-
tutorials/ebd-pico-tutorial/ebd-pico-p10/)
Napa Valley College
http://www.napavalley.edu/Library/Pages/AskClinicalQ
uestionsinPICOTFormat.aspx
(http://www.napavalley.edu/Library/Pages/AskClinicalQuestionsinPICOTFormat.aspx)